How to choose ANA, Aeroplan, or Avios
This is the practical operating checklist. Use it before applying, transferring points, or calling a bank.
- Start with route and cabin, not the loyalty program
- Search ANA for round-trip Star Alliance options
- Search Aeroplan for flexible Star Alliance and partner options
- Search Avios for short-haul or specific partner routes
- Compare fuel surcharges and cancellation rules
- Transfer Amex points only after confirming bookable award seats
The fast answer
ANA can be attractive for round-trip premium-cabin redemptions, Aeroplan is often more flexible for Star Alliance and mixed partners, and Avios can work well for short-haul or specific partner flights. The best choice is route-specific.
Start with the trip, not the program
A common mistake is choosing a program because a blog says it has high value. Instead, choose the city pair, date range, cabin, and traveler count first. Then check which program can actually book that itinerary.
ANA: powerful but less forgiving
ANA can offer strong value, but it often requires round-trip planning, careful award rules, and attention to fuel surcharges. It is better for travelers willing to research before transferring.
Aeroplan: flexible and beginner-friendly
Aeroplan can be easier to use across Star Alliance and select partners. It may price higher than the theoretical sweet spots, but its routing flexibility and online booking can make it practical.
Avios: simple wins on the right routes
Avios is not one program; it is a currency across several related programs. It can be useful for short-haul flights and selected partners, but fees and availability vary widely.
Decision checklist
Before transferring Amex points, confirm award seats, taxes, partner rules, transfer time, cancellation fees, and whether a transfer bonus changes the math.
Original decision table
| Entity | How to use it safely |
|---|---|
| American Express Membership Rewards | Use as a research entity, then confirm current rules with official program terms before acting. |
| ANA Mileage Club | Use as a research entity, then confirm current rules with official program terms before acting. |
| Air Canada Aeroplan | Use as a research entity, then confirm current rules with official program terms before acting. |
| British Airways Avios | Use as a research entity, then confirm current rules with official program terms before acting. |
| Virgin Atlantic | Use as a research entity, then confirm current rules with official program terms before acting. |
Related GlobalHotelTravel guides
Chase Ultimate Rewards transfer partners
How to evaluate UR transfer value.
Bilt Rewards guide
Rent earning and transfer partner basics.
World of Hyatt points value
A conservative hotel points framework.
Reconsideration line checklist
What to prepare after a denial.
Credit card hub
All GlobalHotelTravel card guides.
Travel rewards hub
Miles, points and transfer strategy.
FAQ
Is ANA always the best Amex transfer partner?
No. ANA can be excellent for certain round-trip awards, but it is not always the easiest or cheapest option after fees and rules.
Is Aeroplan better for beginners?
Often yes, because Aeroplan is relatively flexible and easier to search online, but value still depends on the route.
Can I transfer Amex points back after moving them?
Usually no. Treat every transfer as final.